更多意見


第 4 部分

提名委員會的選民基礎
問題1:誰應有權選出提名委員會委員?
由 Wu Kwan Cheung 2014-11-17 19:01:11
除了投票權,更要有提名提名委員會委員候選人的權利。

由 Allen Uhomist 2014-07-29 06:53:43
除了第3部分所提及外,獲1000名有效選民聯署推薦者,可成為增選提委,權力和其他提委無異,惟提委會整體總人數不得超過3000人。

由 Lui Kenneth Kin Wai 2014-07-23 14:07:05
若非全港選民享有同等提名權,該選舉不應被稱為普選

由 Joe 2014-06-18 15:41:17
由於提名委員會由直選議員組成,全港選民均有權選提委。

由 Brian 2014-05-11 23:07:44
As Hong Kong\'s population exceeds 7 million, it only makes sense that more than 250000 people vote for the politicians and leaders that will determine the future of Hong Kong. However, a large number of voters will also result in inevitable chaos as well as a higher risk of uneducated voting. Therefore the best solution is to have a electorate base that is significantly greater than the current amount of 250000 but also one that does not exceed a specific amount (general electorate).

由 Jasmine Kan 2014-05-09 23:24:30
250,000 individuals and bodies is only around 7% of the general electorate in Hong Kong. I believe that the electorate base should be larger in order to have more voices to be heard during the election process. Hence, a larger electorate base can allow people representing all industries to vote instead of having company votes only consisting industrial, commercial, and financial subsectors and not other subsectors such as labour/social welfare.

由 Mike Hung 2014-05-06 17:41:06
是誰說提名委員會一定要由少數人主宰握權的?

由 Wong Yin Pok Asgard 2014-05-06 16:52:46
惟新移民之影響亦應加入考量,還有上次立法會選舉種票等的問題

由 Yeung Dit Yan 2014-05-06 10:35:36
第四界別中大部分委員的選民基礎應是全港選民。

由 Chen Chapman 2014-05-04 00:10:17
建議由全體立法會議員組成特首提名委員會,然後由全港市民一人一票選特首,此舉可形成內閣政制, 又符合基本法有關特首提名委員會的規定。 機構提名則基本法所無,故不可考慮。

由 李樂軒 2014-05-04 00:09:23
本人建議提名委員會的組成方法就是所有合資格的選民自動成為提名委員會的一員,毋須選舉。

由 Chan Sau Yi 2014-05-03 23:49:50
本人主張於2016年全數立法會議員由直選產生,提名委員會則由民選區議員和直選立法會議員組成。

由 Bosco Li 2014-05-03 03:55:23
The general electorate can decide the Chief Executive so they should also have the power to decide the members of the nominating committee.

由 周頌堯 2014-05-03 00:52:19
目前第一至第三界別均無視長期在家照顧子女或長者的人士,以及退休人士以往的貢獻。本人提出全港選民均應有權選出提名委員會委員。

由 林栢熙 2014-05-02 23:23:18
2015年區議會,讓全港選民投票選民選議員 當選議員可以提名一個候選人

由 Rishi Kukreja 2014-05-02 22:45:58
The fairest way is for all registered voters to be able to have a say in who should be part of the NC on an equal footing.

由 Ryan Chiu 2014-05-02 18:14:28
沒有選民基礎的提委會, 不過中共的橡皮圖章!

由 KS Wong 2014-05-02 15:43:56
因另有公眾提名權給非選舉委員會的選民。

由 sn HO 2014-05-01 00:40:19
this is common sense!

由 歐陽家和 2014-04-30 17:54:05
選委理論上係代表巿民,或者界別的,但如果前面的代表制度做得唔到,就無用。

由 周婉儀 2014-04-30 03:06:16
由全港市民以普及而平等的方式均衡參與。

由 Cassandra Leigh Ward 2014-04-29 15:26:48
If the will of the Hong Kong people is to be expressed to its full extent, then the general electorate must be used to accomplish it. People should have a say in their own country, not a partial or non-existent say, but one that could possibly change the way that others look at Hong Kong as a country.

由 Erwin Lee 2014-04-28 02:44:08
Just like how the general electorate has the right to decide who is the Chief Executive, they should be allowed to decide who is in the nominating committee to ensure that overall, they are a good reflection to the desires of the public. The possible members should be limited through tests on how knowledgeable in politics they are, and just present their political ideology. The Nominating Committee is not supposed to decide on the Chief Executive, but rather, it is to ensure that the public has made the best vote by checking and analyzing the votes, and deciding the Chief Executive among themselves, so that is why the public should ensure who is there to represent them.

由 Reb 2014-04-27 23:40:32
Based on my limited amount of Hong Kong politics knowledge, I believe the Electorate base serves to elected members in the nominating committee. I agree that the public should have the power to express their will through the nominating committee that they indirectly elected. Resemble to United State\'s electoral college, a general electorate is the most direct expression of democracy (without direct democracy). However, if the proposed model is successful, a general electorate will be unnecessary as the public can directly express their will through chief executive election. In order to ensure the public\'s design will benefit society as a whole, nominating committee member must be well-educated, trained, and calm. This is made possible if the electorate carefully selects the members of the nominating committee.

由 Jessica 2014-04-27 23:16:08
By using an electorate base larger than that of the existing Election Committee but smaller than the general electorate, it will give the people more voice to choose who should be in the Nominating Committee. The more people there are, the more opinions are heard.

由 David 2014-04-27 18:34:54
I believe in the democracy aspect of “the more the better”. The existing electorate base only consists of 250,000 individuals registered to vote. This is number is not even 5% of the entire population in Hong Kong. By providing the general electorate (3.5 million) the power to choose the Nominating committee, I believe it is a better reflection of the “Will of the People” compared to just using the electorate base.

由 Norma Wong 2014-04-27 14:10:05
隨機抽出,如陪審員,不用選舉。

由 霍漢橋 2014-04-18 23:05:31
由於提名委員會由全體立法會議員組成, 其選民基礎與立法會議員的選民基礎一樣。

由 陳沛曦 2014-04-17 00:29:41
提名委員會的意義在於代表全港選民選出數個受較多人支持的行政長官的候選人,因此提委會委員應該由香港選民以一人一票選出並均衡代表各個選民。

由 何境豐 2013-12-25 10:58:56
提名委員應該由全港選民選舉產生,每一位選民都有自己所屬的界別。

由 陈灵平 2013-12-19 22:15:09
现在是有组织想操纵选举,那么就要针锋相对,坚持公民自由选举的权利。

由 黃君亮 2013-12-11 01:02:59
將全港選民分別按其職業,專業技能或意向劃入各界別後,進行各界別間選選出2400人為選舉委員

由 Man Chun Wai 2013-12-09 08:27:38
應根據人口普查/選民登記計劃中填報的職業來分配該選民屬於哪個界別。務求所有居民(注: 包括 18 歲以上非選民) 可獲得一個界別分配。(惟政界則非以選舉產生, 該以目前的分配為準 [全部 港區人大, 港區政協立法會, 鄉議局及全體民選區議員] )

由 David TIU 2013-12-05 16:29:54
目前選舉委員會的選民基礎,加上所有立法會功能組別的個人選民;另外,功能組別公司票應分拆成該公司的個別管理層和管理級專業人士。

由 Alan Lau 2013-12-05 00:19:34
以分區直選,一人四票方式選出提民委員會委員。體現公平和民主。

由 Kyle Chan 2013-12-04 15:03:19
加入全體民選區議員

由 Tenny Hui 2013-12-04 14:39:36
提名委員會應為現任直選立法局(35+5)再加全港區議員.

由 Leo Yeung 2013-12-04 13:49:58
選民會自動成為委員。

由 KCM 2013-12-04 08:58:13
Preferrably, but the broader the better

由 張博文 2013-12-04 07:57:36
大部分委員應由區議員及立法會議員組成。

由 ken woo 2013-12-04 00:26:30
既然有超級區議員,何不有超級提名委員呢?四大界別組別一為舊1200人組成,四大界別組別二擴大為在職之漁民,工商專業人員,勞工,政界由區議員立法會議員員工義工及會員組成,申請做提名委員條件係年滿三十歲,必須係香港永久居民並無外國居留權

由 劉穎匡 2013-12-03 13:18:36
按照立法會選舉方式選出。

由 Yin Chi Chan 2013-12-03 13:16:38
Nomination committee members are directly elected District or Legislative Councils.

由 Jennifer Eagleton 2013-11-25 10:57:12
In addition to directly elected district counsellors and legislators, some individuals - ordinary members of the public - who would like to be a part of the nominating committee, would have to be nominated by a certain percentage of the public in order to become a part of the committee. They could hold this position on the committee for around 10 years.

由 C K Low 2013-11-24 12:11:57
I have articulated a model in my article titled SELECTING THE CHIEF EXECUTIVE OF HONG KONG IN 2017 which is available at www.ssrn.com/author=332882

由 何濼生 2013-11-22 00:20:42
新增提委應廣及全港選民。

由 Guest 0000-00-00 00:00:00
提名委員會的意義在於代表全港選民選出數個受較多人支持的行政長官的候選人,因此提委會委員應該由香港選民以一人一票選出並均衡代表各個選民。

由 Guest 0000-00-00 00:00:00
.